This is my Looks Like a Poncho! An adapted version of the original Looks Like Rain Scarf pattern.

The finish on the bottom edge allows all sorts of different edgings to be applied. I nearly went for a fringe but didn’t have enough yarn - I would have needed another ball.
I considered the original pompom trim and very nearly went with rings. In the end, I worked a sort of ‘pointy thing’!

It would work equally well with aran yarn and even chunky, to give a warmer winter weight.