dgou's projects
Yarn consumption of Crochet vs. Knitting
Finished
May 20 2014
May 31 2014
Project info
Yarn consumption of Crochet vs. Knitting
Crochet
Hooks & yarn
5.0 mm (H)
Plymouth Yarn Galway Worsted
0.39 skeins = 81.9 yards (74.9 meters), 39 grams
Kid Ewe Knot in Bridgeville, Pennsylvania
Notes

2014/06/03:

Done! Actually Laurie finished her swatch on 2014/05/31 but I wasn’t able to be there for the cast-off.

The knitting sample is 18” long and the crochet is 15”. Width’s are close. The crochet sample is curling, so I measured from the middle of the swatches.

Neither swatch was washed. Neither swatch was blocked.

A difference of 3” means I would need 1/5th, or 20% more yarn, at least in those stitches.


2014/05/20:

Having recently been exposed to the “Oh, crochet uses 1/3rd more yarn than knitting” “common wisdom”, I went looking and found FearlessLeaderCLF’s blog posting on that very subject: http://www.crochetliberationfront.com/2012/02/clf-myth-bu...

As I was in Kid Ewe Knot when I last heard that claim, I asked LaurieG63, a co-owner, if we could do some science and try to reproduce Laurie Wheeler’s results. Laurie G went to the back of the shop to get some yarn for the test. Using a precision scale we divided it in half, 39g each (the skein was not full).

This is the crochet half of the test:
19 sc across
70 rows (plus a few into row 71)

I’ll measure the size in inches when Laurie G finishes her swatch in knitting (same width).

The goal is to have the swatches in the store, along with tags describing the details of each swatch, so that customers could see ‘hands on’ how much fabric you get from each technique. (the tags shown in the photos are just temporary)

viewed 141 times
Finished
May 20 2014
May 31 2014
 
About this pattern
Personal pattern (not in Ravelry)
About this yarn
by Plymouth Yarn
Worsted
100% Wool
210 yards / 100 grams
dgou's star rating

14162 projects

stashed 8412 times

  • Project created: May 24, 2014
  • Updated: June 3, 2014