I made the medium size - not too fitted, not too slouchy. It is great.

I liked the tubular cast on and the look it gave. Was a little tricky, but worth it.

I ran out of yarn with only a few rows left to go so had to find another skein since my LYS didn’t have it. Fortunately that wasn’t a disaster since I did find it online. Except I was aiming to use up the one skein I had and now I have 3/4 of a skein. And a hat I guess.